AT&T Inc (Dallas, Texas, U.S.A.) was dealt a blow on Tuesday as the top U.S. communications regulator sought to have its planned $39 billion purchase of T-Mobile USA (Bellevue, Wash., U.S.A.) sent to an administrative law judge for review. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chairman Julius Genachowski sent a draft order to his fellow commissioners, citing FCC staff findings that the deal would significantly diminish competition and lead to massive job losses.
"The record clearly shows that -- in no uncertain terms -- this merger would result in a massive loss of U.S. jobs and investment," a senior FCC official said.
The agency also concluded that the merger would not result in significantly more buildout of next generation 4G wireless service than would occur absent the transaction. AT&T argues the deal will accelerate its expansion of high-speed wireless service to nearly all Americans.
The U.S. Justice Department went to court in August to oppose AT&T's purchase of T-Mobile from Deutsche Telekom AG (Bonn, Germany) on antitrust grounds. A trial in that case is due to begin on February 13.
Any administrative hearing at the FCC, which is charged with evaluating the public interest merits of the deal, would begin after the antitrust trial, an FCC official said.
AT&T called the FCC action "disappointing" and disputed the agency's conclusion that its T-Mobile deal, with $8 billion in broadband investment and commitments on job preservation and enhancement, would result in the loss of jobs and investment.
The FCC recently said its $4.5 billion annual fund to promote broadband to underserved communities would create 500,000 jobs over the next six years.
"This notion, that when government spends money on broadband it creates jobs, but when a private company spends money it doesn't, is clearly wrong on its face," said Jim Cicconi, AT&T's top executive for external and legislative affairs.
Mizuho analyst Michael Nelson said the move adds another hurdle to AT&T's prospects for closing the deal. "It's like the FCC is piling on to the DOJ's blocking of the deal," he said.
Analysts at Stifel Nicolaus added that "such an extended FCC review could put added pressure on T-Mobile to seek to exit the merger."
AT&T had hoped to close the deal by the first quarter of 2012.
Genachowski's order still requires approval by a majority of commissioners but an administrative hearing seems likely unless the antitrust case results in a permanent injunction against the transaction, making the FCC hearing irrelevant.
Genachowski is expected to get the support of his two fellow Democrats on the panel. The agency was left with only one Republican after Meredith Attwell Baker's departure in May.
Acquiring T-Mobile would vault AT&T into the leading position in the U.S. wireless market. The current industry leader is Verizon Wireless (New York), a venture of Verizon Communications Inc and Vodafone Group Plc (London, England).
Sprint Nextel Corp (Overland Park, Kan., U.S.A.), the third largest U.S. carrier, and a regional competitor, C Spire (Ridgefield, Miss., U.S.A.), have also filed a lawsuit to stop AT&T's purchase of T-Mobile, the fourth largest U.S. operator.
(Reporting by Jasmin Melvin in Washington D.C.; Editing by Tim Dobbyn)