India court orders licenses cancelled in telecom scandal


India's Supreme Court ordered on Thursday telecoms licenses issued under a scandal-tainted 2008 sale be revoked, striking a decisive blow against corruption that plagues the country and roiling the world's second biggest cellular market. The ruling applies to 122 licenses held by eight operators but potentially affects fewer than 5% of users in a fiercely competitive market crowded with more than a dozen players.

Market leaders such as Bharti Airtel (New Delhi, India) and Vodafone (London), which last month scored a big win when the Supreme Court ruled it was not liable for $2.2 billion in tax, are poised to benefit from the ruling.

The licenses affected include those held by Unitech Wireless, a joint venture of Norway's state-backed Telenor (Fornebu, Norway) and Indian real estate firm Unitech (Gurgaon, India), which has been the most aggressive of the newer operators and had more than 36 million subscribers in the country as of December.

"We have been unfairly treated as we simply followed the government process we were asked to," the Telenor joint venture, which operates as Uninor, said in a statement."We are shocked to see that Uninor is being penalized for faults the court has found in the government process."

Affected license holders can operate for four months, during which regulators will come up with new market rules. Freed-up spectrum will be auctioned, which could bring a multi-billion dollar windfall to a deficit-strapped government.

The 2008 sale of the licenses was at below-market prices, costing the exchequer as much as $36 billion in lost revenues and leading to political gridlock. The telecoms scandal is the biggest of several that have emerged during Singh's second term and triggered street protests last year.

"It is a historic judgment. It is trying to break a corrupt nexus between business and politics," said political analyst Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, who was one of petitioners in the case.

Two ministers, including former telecoms minister Andimuthu Raja who presided over the 2008 grant process, have resigned. Raja is in jail awaiting trial.

While the ruling may revive investor worries about the uncertainty of doing business in Asia's third-largest economy, it could also build confidence in the role of the judiciary and broader efforts to crack down on corruption.

India is the world's second-largest cellular market by subscribers, with 894 million at the end of December, although fierce competition means call rates are among the lowest.  Investors and operators have long called for consolidation in the crowded industry, and Thursday's ruling stands to benefit the country's biggest operators.

"This verdict is good news for established incumbent operators and in the short term, we are likely to see some increase in tariffs," said Benoy C.S., a director at consulting firm Frost & Sullivan. Shares in Bharti, the world's fifth-largest carrier by subscribers, ended 6.8% higher while Idea gained 3%, reversing earlier losses. Unitech fell 7%.

Carriers whose licenses were ordered revoked include those of the local joint ventures of Abu Dhabi's Etisalat and Russia's Sistema, as well as Telenor.

"For foreign investors, it is very bad news. What mistake did they do? They partnered with Indian companies, invested lots of money and followed the process of that time," said Rishi Sahai, director at consultancy Cogence Advisors.

Affected companies are expected to fight the verdict. Sistema's India unit said it "reserves the right to protect its interests by using all available judicial remedies".

India's big operators crave more bandwidth to accommodate surging usage in the country of 1.2 billion, so if the spectrum is auctioned it could command a premium. The state auditor has said the spectrum bundled with the 122 licenses would be worth $22.7 billion at the price paid in the 3G auction in 2010, although 2G spectrum is likely to command a lower price.

"Whether this auction will be opened for all operators or will be open only for the people whose licenses are being cancelled -- that will determine the demand-supply equation," said Ashish Basil, a partner in Ernst & Young's telecom group.

India's image as an investment destination was dented over the past year as the economy slowed, government reforms stalled and the telecoms scandals along with high profile graft cases heightened concerns about government policies.

"This is a collective failure of the government of India," Subramanian Swamy, an opposition politician and also a petitioner in the case, said following the ruling.

In declaring the licenses "illegal and quashed," the court said in its ruling that the process of awarding them "was wholly arbitrary, capricious and contrary to public interest apart from being violative of the doctrine of equality".

Police have charged six companies and 19 people, among them a billionaire owner of the Essar Group; top executives of Telenor's and Etisalat's India ventures and three from billionaire Anil Ambani's Reliance Group. Telenor and Etisalat say the case should not involve them because the licenses were issued before they bought into the Indian market.

Other owners of licenses ordered cancelled include Loop Telecom Pvt Ltd; Videocon Telecommunications, part of India's Videocon group; and S-Tel, part-owned by Batelco. Thirteen licenses held by Idea, of which it is using seven, and three by Tata Teleservices are also affected.

(Additional reporting by Rajesh Kumar Singh and Mumbai newsroom; Writing by Tony Munroe and Frank Jack Daniel; Editing by Robert Birsel)


Featured Reports

Mobile Infrastructure in China

Historically, network infrastructure is the most expensive component in a mobile operator's overall CAPEX, which holds true in China, the biggest and fastest growing 4G market in the world. This report provides an in-depth overview of market revenue, equipment shipments, and the competitive landscape for carriers.  Buy now